Mathematical Characterization of Changes in Fear During Exposure Therapy

Published:January 25, 2021DOI:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bpsc.2021.01.005

      Abstract

      Background

      During exposure therapy, patients report increases in fear that generally decrease within and across exposure sessions. Our main aim was to characterize these changes in fear ratings mathematically; a secondary aim was to test whether the resulting model would help to predict treatment outcome.

      Methods

      We applied tools of computational psychiatry to a previously published dataset in which 30 women with spider phobia were randomly assigned to virtual-reality exposures in a single context or in multiple contexts (n = 15 each). Patients provided fear ratings every minute during exposures. We characterized fear decrease within exposures and return of fear between exposures using a set of mathematical models; we selected the best model using Bayesian techniques. In the multiple-contexts group, we tested the predictions of the best model in a separate, test exposure, and we investigated the ability of model parameters to predict treatment outcome.

      Results

      The best model characterized fear decrease within exposures in both groups as an exponential decay with constant decay rate across exposures. The best model for each group had only two parameters but captured with remarkable accuracy the patterns of fear change, both at the group level and for individual subjects. The best model also made remarkably accurate predictions for the test exposure. One of the model’s parameters helped predict treatment outcome.

      Conclusions

      Individual patterns of fear change during exposure therapy can be characterized mathematically. This mathematical characterization helps predict treatment outcome.

      Keywords

      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      References

        • Abramowitz J.S.
        • Deacon B.J.
        • Whiteside S.P.
        Exposure Therapy for Anxiety: Principles and Practice.
        2nd ed. The Guilford Press, New York2019
        • Benito K.G.
        • Walther M.
        Therapeutic process during exposure: Habituation model.
        J Obsessive Compuls Relat Disord. 2015; 6: 147-157
        • McSweeney F.K.
        • Swindell S.
        Common processes may contribute to extinction and habituation.
        J Gen Psychol. 2002; 129: 364-400
        • Shiban Y.
        • Pauli P.
        • Mühlberger A.
        Effect of multiple context exposure on renewal in spider phobia.
        Behav Res Ther. 2013; 51: 68-74
        • Marks I.M.
        Behavioral treatments of phobic and obsessive compulsive disorders: A critical appraisal.
        in: Hersen M. Eisler R.M. Miller P.M. Progress in Behavior Modification. 1st ed. Academic Press, New York1975: 75-168
        • Foa E.B.
        • Kozak M.J.
        Emotional processing of fear: Exposure to corrective information.
        Psychol Bull. 1986; 99: 20-35
        • Bjork R.A.
        • Bjork E.L.
        Optimizing treatment and instruction: Implications of a new theory of disuse.
        in: Nilsson L.-G. Ohta N. Memory and Society: Psychological Perspectives. Psychology Press, 2006: 116-140
        • Sripada R.K.
        • Rauch S.A.M.
        Between-session and within-session habituation in prolonged exposure therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder: A hierarchical linear modeling approach.
        J Anxiety Disord. 2015; 30: 81-87
        • Culver N.C.
        • Vervliet B.
        • Craske M.G.
        Compound extinction: Using the Rescorla–Wagner model to maximize exposure therapy effects for anxiety disorders.
        Clin Psychol Sci. 2015; 3: 335-348
        • Pine D.S.
        Clinical advances from a computational approach to anxiety.
        Biol Psychiatry. 2016; 82: 385-387
        • Maia T.V.
        • Frank M.J.
        From reinforcement learning models to psychiatric and neurological disorders.
        Nat Neurosci. 2011; 14: 154-162
        • Huys Q.J.M.
        • Maia T.V.
        • Frank M.J.
        Computational psychiatry as a bridge from neuroscience to clinical applications.
        Nat Neurosci. 2016; 19: 404-413
        • Maia T.V.
        Introduction to the series on computational psychiatry.
        Clin Psychol Sci. 2015; 3: 374-377
        • Rankin C.H.
        • Abrams T.
        • Barry R.J.
        • Bhatnagar S.
        • Clayton D.F.
        • Colombo J.
        • et al.
        Habituation revisited: An updated and revised description of the behavioral characteristics of habituation.
        Neurobiol Learn Mem. 2009; 92: 135-138
        • Balooch S.B.
        • Neumann D.L.
        • Boschen M.J.
        Extinction treatment in multiple contexts attenuates ABC renewal in humans.
        Behav Res Ther. 2012; 50: 604-609
        • Andreatta M.
        • Leombruni E.
        • Glotzbach-Schoon E.
        • Pauli P.
        • Mühlberger A.
        Generalization of contextual fear in humans.
        Behav Ther. 2015; 46: 583-596
        • Thomas B.L.
        • Vurbic D.
        • Novak C.
        Extensive extinction in multiple contexts eliminates the renewal of conditioned fear in rats.
        Learn Motiv. 2009; 40: 147-159
        • Mystkowski J.L.
        • Craske M.G.
        • Echiverri A.M.
        Treatment context and return of fear in spider phobia.
        Behav Ther. 2002; 33: 399-416
        • Waters W.F.
        • McDonald D.G.
        Repeated habituation and overhabituation of the orienting response.
        Psychophysiology. 1976; 13: 231-235
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Winterbauer N.E.
        • Todd T.P.
        Relapse processes after the extinction of instrumental learning: Renewal, resurgence, and reacquisition.
        Behav Processes. 2012; 90: 130-141
        • Rinck M.
        • Becker E.S.
        • Pössel P.
        Fragebogen zur Angst vor Spinnen (FAS) [Questionnaire for Fear of Spiders (FSQ)].
        in: Hoyer J. Margraf J. Angst-diagnostik Grundlagen und Testverfahren. Springer, Berlin2003: 435-438
        • Szymanski J.
        • O’Donohue W.
        Fear of Spiders Questionnaire.
        J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry. 1995; 26: 31-34
        • Wang D.
        A neural model of synaptic plasticity underlying short-term and long-term habituation.
        Adapt Behav. 1993; 2: 111-129
        • Stanley J.C.
        Computer simulation of a model of habituation.
        Nature. 1976; 261: 146-148
        • Culver N.C.
        Extinction-based processes for enhancing the effectiveness of exposure therapy. Doctoral dissertation, University of California, Los Angeles, California.
        2013
        • Dayan P.
        • Abbott L.F.
        Theoretical Neuroscience: Computational and Mathematical Modeling of Neural Systems.
        MIT Press, Cambridge, MA2001
        • Daunizeau J.
        • Adam V.
        • Rigoux L.
        VBA: A probabilistic treatment of nonlinear models for neurobiological and behavioural data.
        PLoS Comput Biol. 2014; 10e1003441
        • Rigoux L.
        • Stephan K.E.
        • Friston K.J.
        • Daunizeau J.
        Bayesian model selection for group studies – Revisited.
        Neuroimage. 2014; 84: 971-985
        • Stephan K.E.
        • Penny W.D.
        • Daunizeau J.
        • Moran R.J.
        • Friston K.J.
        Bayesian model selection for group studies.
        Neuroimage. 2009; 46: 1004-1017
        • Newell A.
        • Rosenbloom P.S.
        Mechanisms of skill acquisition and the law of practice.
        in: Anderson J.R. Cognitive Skills and Their Acquisition. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ1981: 1-55
        • Heathcote A.
        • Brown S.
        The power law repealed: The case for an exponential law of practice.
        Psychon Bull Rev. 2000; 7: 185-207
        • Newell K.M.
        • Mayer-Kress G.
        • Liu Y.-T.
        Human learning: Power laws or multiple characteristic time scales?.
        Tutor Quant Methods Psychol. 2006; 2: 66-76
        • Craske M.G.
        • Kircanski K.
        • Zelikowsky M.
        • Mystkowski J.L.
        • Chowdhury N.
        • Baker A.S.
        Optimizing inhibitory learning during exposure therapy.
        Behav Res Ther. 2008; 46: 5-27
        • Lara R.
        • Arbib M.A.
        A model of the neural mechanisms responsible for pattern recognition and stimulus specific habituation in toads.
        Biol Cybern. 1985; 51: 223-237
        • Button K.S.
        • Ioannidis J.P.A.
        • Mokrysz C.
        • Nosek B.A.
        • Flint J.
        • Robinson E.S.J.
        • Munafò M.R.
        Power failure: Why small sample size undermines the reliability of neuroscience.
        Nat Rev Neurosci. 2013; 14: 365-376
        • Steyerberg E.W.
        • Harrell F.E.
        Statistical models for prognostication.
        in: Max M.B. Lynn J. Interactive Textbook on Clinical Symptom Research. 2003 (Available at:) (Accessed September 15, 2019)
        • Kandel E.
        • Siegelbaum S.A.
        Cellular mechanisms of implicit memory storage and the biological basis of individuality.
        in: Kandel E. Schwartz J.H. Jessell T.M. Siegelbaum S.A. Hudspeth A.J. Principles of Neural Science. 5th ed. McGraw-Hill, New York2013: 1461-1486
        • Plendl W.
        • Wotjak C.T.
        Dissociation of within- and between-session extinction of conditioned fear.
        J Neurosci. 2010; 30: 4990-4998
        • Gillihan S.J.
        • Foa E.B.
        Fear extincion and emotional processing theory: A critical review.
        in: Schachtman T.R. Reilly S.S. Associative Learning and Conditioning Theory: Human and Non-Human Applications. Oxford University Press, New York2011: 27-43
        • Milad M.R.
        • Rosenbaum B.L.
        • Simon N.M.
        Neuroscience of fear extinction: Implications for assessment and treatment of fear-based and anxiety related disorders.
        Behav Res Ther. 2014; 62: 17-23
        • Averell L.
        • Heathcote A.
        The form of the forgetting curve and the fate of memories.
        J Math Psychol. 2011; 55: 25-35
        • Gershman S.J.
        • Blei D.M.
        • Niv Y.
        Context, learning, and extinction.
        Psychol Rev. 2010; 117: 197-209
        • Pearce J.M.
        A model for stimulus generalization in Pavlovian conditioning.
        Psychol Rev. 1987; 94: 61-73
        • Rudy J.W.
        • O'Reilly RC
        Conjunctive representations, the hippocampus, and contextual fear conditioning.
        Cogn Affect Behav Neurosci. 2001; 1: 66-82
        • Dunsmoor J.E.
        • Niv Y.
        • Daw N.
        • Phelps E.A.
        Rethinking extinction.
        Neuron. 2015; 88: 47-63
        • Morey R.D.
        Confidence intervals from normalized data: A correction to Cousineau (2005).
        Tutor Quant Methods Psychol. 2008; 4: 61-64
        • Bolker B.M.
        Ecological Models and Data in R.
        Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ2008